Thanks Bert for the reply but having these macros in ompi/version.h only if a special option is given to configure is useless for what I would like to enable in OpenMPI with the present suggestion.
This is because the whole idea is to make it possible to write portable MPI compliant C/C++ programs that are able to chose to use or not workarounds for eventual bugs in OpenMPI at compile time based on the exact OpenMPI version.
Declaring the versions macros I suggested would make it possible to dectect at compilation if the current OpenMPI version is affected by a specific bug and to eventually activate a workaround if possible (or terminate compilation with #error preprocessor directive if no workaround exists). With the help of the existing OPEN_MPI macro these checks could be easilly ignored when using an MPI implantation other than OpenMPI.
And this would be very convenient since the application would adjust itself to the OpenMPI implentation without any user intervention.
What I am describing is a common practice. I have checks in my code that check for example ROMIO_VERSION or to activate workarounds for known bugs or checks for __GNUC__ or __INTEL_COMPILER to activate features in newer gcc or icc compilers versions (like the "restrict" pointer qualifier).
But to do similar things with OpenMPI we need these version OMPI_ macro defined by default in mpi.h. They have to be always defined otherwise the save no burden for users.
> you can build your ompi with --with-devel-headers and use the header
> #define OMPI_MAJOR_VERSION 1
> #define OMPI_MINOR_VERSION 1
> #define OMPI_RELEASE_VERSION 4
> #define OMPI_GREEK_VERSION ""
> Audet, Martin wrote:
> > Hi,
> > I would like to suggest you to add macros indicating the version of the
> > OpenMPI library in the C/C++ header file mpi.h analogous to the
> > parameter constants in the Fortran header file:
> > parameter (OMPI_MAJOR_VERSION=1)
> > parameter (OMPI_MINOR_VERSION=1)
> > parameter (OMPI_RELEASE_VERSION=4)
> > parameter (OMPI_GREEK_VERSION="")
> > parameter (OMPI_SVN_VERSION="r13362")
> > This would be very handy if someone discover a bug XYZ and a workaround
> > for it in OpenMPI versions before (and not including) 1.1.4 for example
> > and wants his code to be portable on many OpenMPI versions and also on
> > other MPI-2 implementations. In this situation he could do something
> > like this in a common C header file:
> > #ifdef OPEN_MPI
> > /* true iff (x.y.z < u.v.w) */
> > #define DOTTED_LESS_THAN(x,y,z, u,v,w) \
> > (((x) < (u)) || (((x) == (u)) && (((y) < (v)) || (((y) == (v)) &&
> > ((z) < (w))))))
> > # if DOTTED_LESS_THAN(OMPI_MAJOR_VERSION, OMPI_MINOR_VERSION,
> > OMPI_RELEASE_VERSION, 1,1,4)
> > # define USE_MPI_WORKAROUND_XYZ
> > # endif
> > #endif
> > And later in the C source code:
> > #ifdef USE_MPI_WORKAROUND_XYZ
> > /* use the workaround */
> > #else
> > /* use the normal method */
> > #endif
> > Thanks,
> > Martin