Absolutely! Why wait until the 1.4 while we can have that in the
On Jan 15, 2009, at 16:39 , Eugene Loh wrote:
> I don't know what scope of changes require RFCs, but here's a
> trivial change.
> RFC: Eliminate opal_round_up_to_nearest_pow2().
> WHAT: Eliminate the function opal_round_up_to_nearest_pow2().
> WHY: It's poorly written. A clean rewrite would take only
> one line of code, which is best written in-place rather than
> making a function call. Currently, there is only one call
> site, and I expect it to go away. Similar code already inlines
> such computation rather than calling this obscure, unused function.
> WHERE: opal/util
> WHEN: Upon acceptance. For 1.4.
> TIMEOUT: January 30, 2009.
> WHY (details):
> The function opal_round_up_to_nearest_pow2() is defined in
> opal/util/pow2.c and is declared in the corresponding include
> file. It returns the calling argument rounded up to the
> nearest power of 2.
> This code is difficult to read. That is, it is difficult to
> reason about the code's correctness or range of validity or
> its behavior outside the range of validity. Meanwhile, it
> offers no compelling advantage -- e.g., fast performance or
> increased robustness. It is called by only one site, which
> is going away.
> To use the existing function, one must know of its existence,
> include the proper header file, and make the appropriate function
> In contrast, a cleanly written version of this code takes only
> one line of code. Hence, calling sites are cleaner and faster
> if they simply in-line this computation. Further, such code is
> customizable (e.g., round down to a power of 2). Most "round to
> power of 2" computations in OMPI today already simply implement
> this computation themselves rather than calling this obscure
> function. E.g., search on "pow2" in
> WHAT (details):
> - Remove the file opal/util/pow2.c.
> - Remove the file opal/util/pow2.h.
> - In opal/util/Makefile.am, remove pow2.h and pow2.c
> - In ompi/class/ompi_circular_buffer_fifo.h, if the call
> to opal_round_up_to_nearest_pow2() has not already been
> removed, then remove
> #include "opal/util/pow2.h"
> and replace
> size = opal_round_up_to_nearest_pow2(size_of_fifo);
> size = 1;
> while ( size < size_of_fifo)
> size <<= 1;
> or the even more compact
> for (size = 1; size < size_of_fifo; size <<= 1);
> devel mailing list